Home
Shop
New Products
SEASONAL
ON SALE
Chocolate Bars
Milk Chocolate
Dark Chocolate
White Chocolate
Peanut Butter
Challenge Bars
Hot Hot Chocolate
Merchandise
Where To Buy
Events
Become A Retailer
Shop On Faire
Private Label
Contact Us
(FAQ)
Blog
Cart
THE CHALLENGE
Home
/ Shop
Shop
Default sorting
Sort by popularity
Sort by average rating
Sort by latest
Sort by price: low to high
Sort by price: high to low
Showing 1–48 of 65 results
Black Hole Sun Chocolate Bar
$
3.70
Add to cart
Black Ops Chocolate Bar
$
3.95
Add to cart
Claymore Chocolate Bar
$
4.40
Add to cart
Sale!
Coffee Mug: Willy Pete’s Flag Logo
$
8.00
Original price was: $8.00.
$
5.00
Current price is: $5.00.
Add to cart
Sale!
Cold Pack Shipping
$
2.00
Original price was: $2.00.
$
1.50
Current price is: $1.50.
Add to cart
Couch Pogtato Chocolate Bar
$
3.75
Add to cart
Death Breath
$
3.75
Add to cart
Fire Pig Dark Chocolate Bar
$
3.95
Add to cart
Fire Pig Milk Chocolate Bar
$
3.95
Add to cart
Firecracker Chocolate Bar
$
3.75
Read more
Frag Out Chocolate Bar
$
3.95
Add to cart
FunVee Chocolate Bar
$
3.75
Add to cart
Game On Chocolate Bar
$
5.00
Add to cart
Game Over Chocolate Bar
$
3.75
Add to cart
Gift Bag
$
1.00
Add to cart
Gift Certificate
$
10.00
–
$
100.00
Select options
Han-Banero In Carbonite
$
3.70
Add to cart
Sale!
HAT – Multicam Black Cap
$
17.00
Original price was: $17.00.
$
12.00
Current price is: $12.00.
Add to cart
Sale!
HAT – Multicam Cap
$
17.00
Original price was: $17.00.
$
12.00
Current price is: $12.00.
Add to cart
Sale!
HAT – Pink Truckers Cap
$
15.00
Original price was: $15.00.
$
12.00
Current price is: $12.00.
Add to cart
Hearts and Minds Dark Chocolate Bar
$
3.70
Add to cart
Hearts and Minds Milk Chocolate Bar
$
3.70
Add to cart
Sale!
Hoodie: Willy Pete’s Logo and Flag
$
20.00
–
$
24.00
Select options
HOT Hot Chocolate – Single Serving
$
3.00
Add to cart
HOT Hot Chocolate – Three Servings
$
8.00
Add to cart
HumDrumVee Chocolate Bar
$
3.70
Add to cart
LAND MINE – Peanut Butter Cup
$
14.00
Add to cart
Loves Me. Loves Me Not Chocolate Bar – 2 Pack
$
7.25
Add to cart
M.O.A.B. (Mother Of All Bars)
$
15.00
Read more
M.O.A.B. 2.0 – Dark
$
18.00
Add to cart
M.O.A.B. 2.0 – Milk
$
18.00
Read more
M.O.A.B. 2.0 – White
$
18.00
Add to cart
M.O.A.B. GOLD (Mother Of All Bars)
$
15.00
Add to cart
Make Your Own Hot Chocolate
$
2.50
–
$
3.00
Select options
Mandatory “Not So” Fun Chocolate Bar
$
5.00
Read more
Mandatory Fun Chocolate Bar
$
4.00
Add to cart
MERICA
$
4.40
Add to cart
Military Bar: U.S. Air Force Chocolate Bar
$
3.60
Add to cart
Military Bar: U.S. Army Chocolate Bar
$
3.60
Add to cart
Military Bar: U.S. Coast Guard Chocolate Bar
$
3.60
Add to cart
Military Bar: U.S. Marines Chocolate Bar
$
3.60
Add to cart
Military Bar: U.S. Navy Chocolate Bar
$
3.60
Add to cart
Military Bar: U.S. Space Force Chocolate Bar
$
3.60
Add to cart
Naughty or Nice Chocolate Bar – 2 Pack
$
7.50
Add to cart
NEMESIS
$
20.00
Add to cart
Patches – Willy Pete’s Flag Logo
$
1.00
Add to cart
Peanut Butter & Jelly Bar
$
3.80
Add to cart
Peanut Butter Bar
$
3.75
Add to cart
1
2
NEXT